BACK TO
CURRENT ISSUE

 

FRONT PAGE:
Greg Howard
And his big stick...
Chapman that is

IRS COLUMNS:

Joy Calderwood
Reviews TV's
Andromeda

Marc Olmsted's
Astro Hell

Sight & Sound

CD Reviews
DVD Reviews

Sight
- Woo Woo
A DVD
Double Bill From
Action's Master

Sound
- Rhino Salutes the
Harlem Renissance,
The Supremes

stand alone

Leaving Las Vegas?
Epstein's Mother
sure hope's so

Word

Woman on the Verge
Aimee Bender

Best Non Fiction of 2001
T he real Moby Dick
In the Heart
of the Sea

Concerts

TECHNOPOP

SoftWare
HardWare

EDITORIAL:

- Monthly Beef
- Write Us
- Letters
- Subscribe
- Submit



Archive
Watch for our newly
remodeled
Archive Section.  
Coming Soon!
CD Feature

RHAPSODIES IN BLACK:
Music and Words From The
Harlem Renaissance
4 CD Set
Rhino

www.rhino.com

Rhapsodies In Black

   The Harlem Renaissance (roughly1915-1937), like the Armenian holocaust or the bombing of Dresden, is a rarely talked about yet monumental event in history. Unlike the holocaust in Turkey or the immolation of Dresden however, the Harlem Renaissance was cause for celebration. Started around 1915 after the death of Booker T. Washington, the Renaissance was ushered in by black artists, writers and performers who, unlike Washington, had not been born into slavery. The freedom of living in a city community like Harlem, allowed blacks, for possibly the first time in their history as Americans, to imagine and create the natural bi-product of decades of suffering: art. While repressed, covert art was made during their years of slavery, this was the first time that their art could be unfurled in the bright light of day. On top of that, it was so amazing that white people flocked to Harlem to witness the spectacle. The Harlem Renaissance beget the Beat Generation of New York, which beget the hippies of San Francisco, which beget the yippees, out of which rose the yuppies. It would seem that the roots of all our most revolutionary and noteworthy movements are black, as coal, as earth, black as the night before the first rays of dawn. Rhino Records four CD set, RHAPSODIES IN BLACK, MUSIC AND WORDS FROM THE HARLEM RENAISSANCE attempts to sample this slice of Americana that is usually only remembered for it's sound bytes: Duke Elllington, the Cotton Club, Langston Hughes. Fortunately for history and the savvy box set collector, Rhino has managed to reach back into the archives of Sony, RCA, UMG and a few choice collections to give a fuller, more vibrant look at a where greatness existed for a short time, than any other collection to date .

Rhapsodies In Black
Duke Ellington

   The music recordings, while re-mastered as well as possible, are not the kind of stereo driven music we are used to. Recording technology, like the rise of this new black culture, was in its infancy and in the end we are lucky to have what we do. Forgiving the technical quality, there is a haunting quality to the recordings present in the collection that makes you yearn for a dim place to listen. As Bert Williams sings "Brother Low Down" or Ethel Waters accompanied by her Jazz Masters belts out "There'll be Some Changes Made" or "Stormy Weather" close your eyes and imagine what it was like to hear something like that for the first time. A favorite of mine on disc three (Preachin' & Prayin') was "My Handy Man" by Victoria Spivey. There is a hopefulness to the music, even below the blue note, that is not present in black music today which lifts the heart even while the soul is feeling low.
   Another hurdle the editors of the set had to get over was the lack of any recordings of spoken word. Poetry and fiction had a place in the Harlem Renaissance on a par with music. Langston Hughes, W.E.B. Dubois, Zora Neale Hurston have survived times short term memory, but lesser known writers like Sterling Brown and Arna Bontemps are also here. The problem is that while their voices live on in print, there were no recordings for Rhino to pilfer. So they did the only thing an LA based retro record company could do, they hired local talent to do the job. I would love to have been around for the meeting where they decided who to commission to read the 20 spoken word pieces in the set. One of the most inspired readings opens disc three. Rap singer Ice-T reads a poem by Claude McKay called, "If We Must Die"." "If we must die, let it not be like hogs/ Hunted and penned in an inglorious spot, / While round us bark the mad and hungry dogs, / Making their mock at our accursed lot....") I understand the necessity of today's bleak up front poetry and song, but to hear passion and anger presented so eloquently is awe-inspiring. Actress Alfre Woodard, a force in her own right, brings life to "I Want to Die While You Love Me" by Georgia Douglas Johnson on disc 4 (Lustin' for Love & Life). Ms. Johnson could have been speaking of the Harlem Renaissance itself when she wrote the lines: "I want to die why you love me, / and never, never see / The glory of this perfect day / Grow dim or cease to be."

Rhapsodies In Black
Bessie Smith


   Any collection is imperfect. It cannot contain be all things to all people, but as with any relationship, compromise is the key. Here are four CD's with 85 tracks full of music, poetry and literature that you won't find put together anywhere else. Certainly not in a beautiful box complete with a thick book of liner notes with essays chronicling the history of the Harlem Renaissance, so run don't walk to the record store.

Carlye Archibeque



SUPREMES BOX SET
4 CD Set
Bonus Cd with Limited Edition
Motown Records

www.motown.com

Supremes Box Set

   Every man, woman and child in America and beyond can probably hum the chorus to "Where Did Our Love Go", and there's a reason for that: it is a perfect pop song. And it's not just a perfect pop song for the sixties, but a perfect pop song forever. It captures the angst and longing of love lost and pain embraced, but there is also a cool calculation to the drama the song invokes that makes you feel like everything is going to be just fine. It was also the first hit for a little girl group on the Motown label. Diana Ross, Florence Ballard, Barbara Martin (who left the group after the first single) and Mary Wilson had been hanging out at the Motown studios singing background and clapping their hands in unison for the likes of Smokey Robinson and the Miracles waiting for their big break for some time. The producers at Barry Gordy's Motown had been trying to find a single that would fit the trio and in August of 1964 they hit gold as "Where Did Our Love Go" displaced Dean Martin's "Everybody Loves Somebody." It stayed on the charts in the number one position for two weeks, proving that misery sells better than happiness. So began the saga of one of the most popular, memorable, dynamic, well dressed musical groups in the world, the Supremes.

The Supremes
Supremes Interview

   This box set chronicles the saga of the Supremes from their very first recorded demo as The Primettes in 1960, to the very last show of "The Supremes" minus Barbara Martin, Florence Ballard and Diana Ross. The box itself is fabulous, pink velvet with a elegant burn-out swirl on the front around an early picture of the group in typical diva pose with sequined gowns and perfect 60's hair: not a care in the world from the looks of it.
   Inside there are 4 discs, the face of each showcasing the Supremes dressed for the decade the disc represents. In a limited edition of the sets there is a fifth disc, "In Person, An Evening with The Supremes" which strings together mostly unreleased live versions of their most popular hits recorded at the height of their popularity. This single disc is almost better than the four that comprise the set. Track 11, "Reflections" live is so dynamic it gave me goose bumps.

Limited Edition Extra Disc
Limited Edition Extra

   That's the only problem with this set, it makes you realize how good the group was at their height and as disc 1 progress to 2 and 3 and finally 4 you feel like you are watching a flower wilt. Reading about the progression of the band with its personality differences and the slow breakdown of the Motown machine that kept them oiled and shinny, its easy to understand why the Supremes shone so brightly for a relatively short time. Diana Ross' desire to be queen, and Motown's desire to be king kept either from being able to hold on to the royal positions they did have.
   Looking over the liner notes it becomes apparent that most of the songs we know the Supremes for were written by the Mowtown team of Holland-Dozier-Holland: "Nothing but Heartache", "Back in my Arms Again", "I Hear a Symphony", "My World is Empty Without You" and on and on. But the relationship was reciprocal: Motown kept the girls in music and sequins and the girls kept Motown at the top of the charts over and over again, but it wasn't really the entity that was Motown, it was the artists that Motown had the good sense to sign. Eventually egos went out of balance and the rest was history. But what history it was.
   This set chronicles the history beautifully with 88 songs, including all the hits and 15 tracks previously unreleased tracks. All the tracks are digitally re-mastered from analog master tapes. The early tracks of The Primettes are fun to listen to and little heard songs like, "Run, Run, Run" and "In and Out of Love", while not perfect pop songs, are good listening too. Also included are the hits the Supremes had with the Temptations and the Four Tops. Finally, the 76 page book is full of beautiful pictures of the girls in full diva regalia, informative discographies, and some great essays on early Motown and the Supremes by Berry Gordy and others. This is the definitive Supremes set

Jane Hinde




Subscribe to
The Independent Reviews Site
Powered by groups.yahoo.com

Back To The Top